If phones are endangering pedestrians, why is this only occurring in America?

      The most significant news and reviews about cars, without any fluff.

      Subscribe to our free daily newsletter to receive the key stories that matter directly to your inbox every weekday.

      In the U.S., pedestrian fatalities are on the rise. Unlike the global trend of smartphone use, the U.S. is the only country experiencing a notable increase in deaths.

      In contrast, both Europe and Japan have seen reductions in these fatalities. These areas maintain safer roadways despite having similar levels of technology adoption.

      Distracted driving isn't the only culprit. Evidence indicates that other elements contribute to the unique challenges faced in America.

      Global comparisons underscore this issue. Nations like Canada and Australia do not reflect the trends seen in the U.S.

      In summary: The pedestrian safety crisis in America is distinct, with the rising number of fatalities not exclusively linked to smartphone use.

      AI-assisted, editor-reviewed content.

      Recently, the New York Times released a critical study regarding America’s ongoing pedestrian safety crisis. Maybe you saw our coverage or read about it elsewhere. Perhaps you have strong opinions on the matter, as we've certainly heard from many of you. At the time of writing, that article gathered over 260 comments solely on our site.

      Many comments express a similar viewpoint: “It’s the cell phones, stupid!”

      But is that really the case? It's a reasonable argument at first glance. The iPhone launched in 2007, and U.S. pedestrian deaths began increasing about two years later, peaking during the pandemic. I understand; I was on my phone a lot during that time as well.

      There is data supporting this widely held belief. A thoughtful reddit user even created a visualization showing the correlation between pedestrian deaths, vehicle weight, and U.S. cell phone adoption. It all seems to fit perfectly, except for one small detail: other countries also have cell phones.

      What does this imply? Simple: If cell phones are the cause for the rise in pedestrian fatalities, we should see this pattern in other countries where smartphone use and vehicle ownership coincide—essentially in the world's leading economies. If you've read this far, you've probably already figured out what I'll say next: The data doesn’t add up.

      Data sourced from https://w3.unece.org/PXWeb/en/Table?IndicatorCode=59, plotted with Google Sheets; visualization enhanced by Gemini.

      Since we value visual data, here's another one. The previous information utilizes public data from the UN Economic Commission for Europe (and U.S. statistics are supported by NHTSA), presenting a clear picture.

      If you’re not satisfied with my trend lines, rest assured others have explored this in greater depth. Regardless of whose data you reference, the trend remains consistent and points in the wrong direction.

      In 2013, pedestrian deaths in the U.S. and Western Europe were roughly equal. This was four years into the reported increase in fatalities in America, and as we've seen, Europe’s steady decline has continued uninterrupted aside from a slight rise in 2016. By 2021, the number of pedestrian fatalities in the U.S. had more than doubled that of Western Europe; according to IIHS, not much has changed since then.

      The situation outside of Europe is also telling. Japan, despite its historical issues with pedestrian safety due to dense development, has seen a decline in fatalities in the same timeframe, adopting a pedestrian-first safety approach. Australia experienced a rise since the pandemic but does not follow the same trend as the U.S., nor does Canada.

      China presents a somewhat ambiguous scenario. One estimate suggests its pedestrian fatality rate could be as high as 17 per 100,000, which, while it might not seem terrible on the surface, indicates a level of danger that would have shocked Americans in urban areas during the 1920s, when the automotive explosion led to a rate of 12 per 100,000. Today, the U.S. pedestrian fatality rate is around 2.3. These figures reflect rapid industrialization, likely disconnected from the number of Chinese citizens absorbed in TikTok.

      Is distracted driving (and walking/cycling) a concern? Absolutely. But can we single it out as the reason America's roads are becoming less safe for pedestrians and cyclists? You can make your own conclusion, but the statistics rarely mislead.

      Have a story tip? Reach out at tips@thedrive.com!