John Deere Agrees to $99 Million Settlement in Major Right-to-Repair Case

      Richard Hamilton Smith/Design Pics Editorial/Universal Images Group via Getty Images

      The most important car news and reviews, no nonsense

      Our complimentary daily newsletter delivers the stories that truly matter to you every weekday.

      Farmers have been battling John Deere for years for the right to repair their machinery, and this week they finally achieved a significant settlement.

      Though the agricultural giant emphasized in a statement that it does not acknowledge any wrongdoing, it has agreed to contribute $99 million to a fund for farms and individuals involved in a class action lawsuit. Specifically, this fund is designated for those who paid authorized John Deere dealers for large equipment repairs since January 2018. This means that plaintiffs may recover between 26% and 53% of the overcharge damages, as detailed in one of the court documents—considerably higher than the usual recovery range of 5% to 15%.

      The settlement also includes an agreement from Deere to provide “the digital tools required for maintenance, diagnostics, and repairs” of tractors, combines, and other machinery for a decade. This aspect is vital, as farmers had previously been forced to hack their machinery's software to make repairs. In 2023, John Deere signed a memorandum of understanding that partially addressed these issues, allowing third parties access to the technology needed for diagnostics and repair, provided that its intellectual property was protected. The settlement reached on Monday appears to be a much more robust (and legally binding) advancement.

      The repercussions of this dispute have been felt well beyond the sales floors of John Deere dealerships, as the prices of used equipment significantly increased due to notorious service challenges. Despite the fact that the cost of older tractors doubled, farmers found them worth the investment because repairs were easier and downtime was reduced. It became commonplace to see $60,000 for a 40-year-old machine.

      Approval from a judge for the settlement is still necessary, although it seems probable. Nonetheless, John Deere still has hurdles to overcome. It is facing another lawsuit from the United States Federal Trade Commission, which alleges that Deere has improperly restricted the repair process.

      The importance of the right-to-repair battle cannot be overstated. While it has clear implications for the agricultural sector, industries like automotive and home appliances are closely watching. Any legal ruling that formally finds John Deere at fault may establish a precedent for others in similar situations. In an era when manufacturers seek ever-increasing control over their products after the sale, every development feels particularly consequential.

      Have a tip or question for the author? Reach out directly: caleb@thedrive.com